You twist open a fresh jar and see a half-inch layer of oil floating above dense peanut solids — that’s the signal you bought the real thing, not a hydrogenated spread. Every jar of all natural peanut butter forces the same daily choice: stir thoroughly and store upside down, or accept a drier first scoop. This guide sorts through the brands that respect that oil layer, comparing stir effort against pure peanut flavor.
I’m Emma — the founder and writer behind Baby Bangs. I have spent years analyzing ingredient lists and production methods in the natural nut butter category, zeroing in on which brands actually use single-ingredient peanuts versus those that sneak in palm oil or sugar.
Whether you need a chunky stir-in for baking or a smooth spread for morning toast, this breakdown of the best all natural peanut butter highlights the brands that keep their labels honest and their flavor pure.
How To Choose The Best All Natural Peanut Butter
The all natural peanut butter aisle has expanded well beyond the two-ingredient jars your grandmother kept in the pantry. Today you will find powders with 88 percent less fat, creamy blends with added sea salt, and super-chunky options packed with visible peanut halves. The right choice depends on how you plan to eat it — straight from the spoon, spread on toast, or mixed into smoothies and baked goods.
Check the ingredient line first
Legitimate all natural peanut butter lists exactly two ingredients: peanuts and salt. Some premium brands skip the salt entirely. If you see palm oil, hydrogenated vegetable oil, sugar, corn syrup, or emulsifiers like mono- and diglycerides, the product is technically a peanut spread, not pure peanut butter. The oil layer on top is not a defect — it is proof the manufacturer did not add stabilizers to keep the solids suspended.
Decide between traditional and powdered
Traditional natural peanut butter retains the full fat content of the peanut, usually around 16 grams per two-tablespoon serving. Powdered versions press out most of the oil, leaving a fine flour that you rehydrate with water. Powders work well in smoothies, oatmeal, and protein shakes because they blend without the heavy fat mouthfeel. If you need a spread for sandwiches, stick with the jarred traditional form — powder reconstituted into paste never matches the original texture.
Consider the grind and jar material
Chunky lovers should look for “super chunky” labels that guarantee visible peanut pieces, while smooth seekers need a brand that grinds fine enough to spread without grit. Glass jars are preferred by purists because they do not impart any plastic taste over long storage, but they add weight to the shipment. Plastic jars are lighter and easier to squeeze when the jar is nearly empty, though some buyers report a faint plastic note if the butter sits for months.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CB’s Nuts Creamunchy | Traditional | Premium flavor experience | USA peanuts, Redmond Real Salt, glass jar | Amazon |
| Teddie Super Chunky | Traditional | Serious chunk lovers | Dry roasted peanuts, no sugar, 26 oz plastic jar | Amazon |
| Teddie Smooth 2-Pack | Traditional | Household bulk buyers | Non-GMO, no added oils, 52 oz total | Amazon |
| Crazy Richard’s Powder | Powdered | Low-cal baking and cooking | Single ingredient peanuts, Glyphosate Residue Free, 32 oz | Amazon |
| Micro Ingredients Powder | Powdered | Protein-forward bulk use | 88% less fat, 10g protein, 4 lb bag | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. CB’s Nuts Salted Creamunchy Peanut Butter
CB’s Nuts uses USA-grown peanuts slow-roasted in small batches and finished with Redmond Real Salt — an unrefined, mineral-rich salt that adds a subtle complexity you will not find in standard sea salt blends. The creamunchy texture lands exactly between creamy and chunky, delivering small peanut bits without the large pieces that can make spreading difficult. Each two-jar pack comes in glass, which preserves the roasted aroma and avoids any plastic off-notes during longer pantry storage.
Oil separation is minimal compared to other natural brands, likely because the slow-roasting process reduces moisture content before grinding. A quick stir brings the butter back to uniform consistency within thirty seconds. The ingredient list stops at peanuts and salt — no palm oil, no added sugar, no stabilizers — making this one of the cleanest labels on the market. Reviewers consistently note that it is the best-tasting natural peanut butter they have ever tried, with a roasted depth that carries into recipes and spreads.
The 2-pack format means you have a backup jar ready, which is useful if you go through a jar every two to three weeks. Each jar holds roughly 16 ounces, slightly smaller than the standard 26-ounce plastic tubs, but the glass packaging justifies the swap for anyone who prioritizes taste purity over raw volume.
Why it’s great
- Redmond Real Salt provides a mineral complexity missing from other natural brands
- Glass jars eliminate any plastic taste and keep the roasted flavor intact
- Minimal oil separation means faster stirring before each use
Good to know
- Smaller 16-ounce jars per pack compared to standard 26-ounce tubs
- Higher sticker price reflects the small-batch production and premium salt
2. Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter, Super Chunky
Teddie’s super chunky variant packs more whole and halved peanut pieces than any competitor in this lineup. Many reviewers describe opening the jar to find the top layer dominated by visible peanut chunks, which makes for a conspicuously crunchy bite every time. The base is dry-roasted peanuts with salt — no sugar, no hydrogenated oils — and the texture is noticeably thicker and less runny than smoother natural butters, almost paste-like until stirred.
That thickness requires genuine effort during the initial stir. The oil separates aggressively in this formulation, so expect a solid half-inch of clear oil on top. Mixing takes about two to three minutes of firm folding rather than quick swirling. Once combined and stored upside down in the refrigerator, the consistency stabilizes and subsequent scoops require minimal effort. The salt level is well-calibrated: salty enough to contrast the roasted peanuts but not so heavy that it overpowers recipes.
The 26-ounce plastic jar offers good volume for the price point, and the brand has been manufacturing in Everett, Massachusetts for decades. It is also gluten-free and vegan certified, making it a safe choice for households with dietary restrictions beyond just natural ingredients.
Why it’s great
- Super chunky texture delivers abundant visible peanut pieces in every bite
- Only peanuts and salt — no hidden sugars or emulsifiers
- Large 26-ounce plastic jar provides strong volume for daily use
Good to know
- Thick paste consistency requires prolonged stirring to reincorporate oil
- Chunks can make spreading on thin crackers or delicate bread difficult
3. Teddie Peanut Butter Smooth 2-Pack
The smooth version of Teddie’s all natural peanut butter is noticeably thinner in consistency than the super chunky variant, which makes it easier to stir and spread. Reviewers specifically note that the initial oil separation is less dramatic — a thin layer rather than the thick cap seen in the chunky jar. The grind is fine enough to glide onto bread without tearing the surface, yet retains enough texture to feel like real ground peanuts rather than a homogenized paste.
This 2-pack delivers 52 ounces total, making it the highest volume option among the traditional butters in this guide. The non-GMO certification and absence of added oils or sugars align with clean-eating goals. A few buyers mentioned that the consistency feels slightly runny compared to competitors, but that looseness actually reduces the arm work during stirring. Once refrigerated, the butter firms up to a spreadable density that holds well on sandwiches without dripping.
The plastic jars are lighter to handle and easier to squeeze for the last tablespoon compared to glass, but the packaging does not protect the flavor as long once opened. If you go through a jar within three to four weeks, the plastic is not an issue. For slower consumers, consider decanting into a glass container after opening.
Why it’s great
- 52 ounces total across two jars offers the best volume in this guide
- Smooth consistency stirs easily and spreads without tearing bread
- Non-GMO and free of added sugars or hydrogenated oils
Good to know
- Some users find the texture slightly runny compared to thicker natural brands
- Plastic jars may impart a subtle taste if stored for extended periods
4. Crazy Richard’s 100% All-Natural Peanut Butter Powder
Crazy Richard’s peanut butter powder contains exactly one ingredient: peanuts. No salt, no sugar, no preservatives. The peanuts are pressed to remove most of the oil, leaving a fine powder that you reconstitute with water, milk, or directly stir into batters and smoothies. The Glyphosate Residue Free certification is rare in the peanut category and matters for buyers who track pesticide exposure in their pantry staples.
The powder reconstitutes into a spreadable paste when mixed at roughly two tablespoons powder to one tablespoon water, though the texture is noticeably drier and less fatty than traditional peanut butter. Where this product truly shines is in baking and cooking — it incorporates into pancake batter, oatmeal, and Greek yogurt without the heavy oil slick that traditional butter leaves. Reviewers also report using it in homemade protein bars, peanut sauces, and even as a coating for chicken tenders.
The 32-ounce bag provides 32 servings at roughly two tablespoons each, which translates to lower per-serving calories and fat compared to traditional butter. It is also kosher certified and gluten-free. The facility processes milk, eggs, fish, shellfish, tree nuts, wheat, and soy, so those with severe cross-contamination concerns should verify their tolerance level before purchasing.
Why it’s great
- Single ingredient — 100 percent US peanuts with no additives at all
- Glyphosate Residue Free certification addresses a real pesticide concern
- Versatile for baking, smoothies, and cooking without adding heavy fat
Good to know
- Reconstituted spread is drier and less satisfying than full-fat peanut butter
- Facility processes multiple allergens including tree nuts and soy
5. Micro Ingredients Pure Peanut Butter Powder
Micro Ingredients offers the largest single bag in this guide at 4 pounds, yielding roughly 107 servings per container. Each serving delivers 10 grams of plant-based protein with 88 percent less fat than traditional peanut butter, making this an efficient protein source for smoothies, shakes, and oatmeal. The powder is made from fresh roasted peanuts with no added sugar or salt, keeping the flavor profile clean and versatile.
The texture is slightly finer than Crazy Richard’s powder — it dissolves more completely in cold liquids without clumping. Reviewers consistently mention the included measuring scoop and note that transferring the powder to a sealed glass jar after opening reduces mess and extends freshness. The peanut flavor is milder than traditional butter, which works well when you want the protein boost without dominating the other ingredients in your recipe. Some users blend it with maple syrup and chickpeas for a fruit dip or mix it with cocoa powder for a homemade low-fat Nutella alternative.
The 4-pound bag is manufactured in a cGMP-compliant facility and is free of soy, dairy, gluten, and tree nuts, which gives it a broader allergen profile compared to Crazy Richard’s. It is also third-party lab tested, though specific certification details are less transparent than the Glyphosate Residue Free seal on the Crazy Richard’s bag.
Why it’s great
- 4-pound bag provides over 100 servings — the best bulk value in this guide
- Dissolves smoothly in cold liquids with minimal clumping
- Free of soy, dairy, gluten, and tree nuts for broad allergen safety
Good to know
- Milder peanut flavor may disappoint those wanting intense roasted notes
- Bulk bag requires transfer to a jar for easy scooping and storage
FAQ
Why does my all natural peanut butter have oil on top?
Is powdered peanut butter as healthy as traditional peanut butter?
How long does all natural peanut butter last after opening?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most users, the best all natural peanut butter winner is the CB’s Nuts Creamunchy because its small-batch roasting, Redmond Real Salt, and glass packaging deliver the cleanest, most flavorful jar available. If you want a super chunky texture with abundant peanut pieces, grab the Teddie Super Chunky. And for low-calorie baking and smoothie protein, nothing beats the single-ingredient purity of Crazy Richard’s Powder.